Trading Card Price History & Guide

Gary Rookie Cards (PSA)

Price Estimation (CIB) USD 19.99 ↑

Estimate from 29 eligible sales, last sold May 2026. No sales in the last 30 days — treat it as a guide price, not a live quote.

#385 most valuable of 457 in Rookie Cards.

Checklists

Sellers View listings → View listings →

The eBay and Amazon buttons above are affiliate links — we may earn a commission on qualifying purchases

Gary Rookie Cards (PSA) is a Trading Card from the Rookie Cards line. Its price history covers 29 eligible sales, the most recent in May 2026.

Gary Rookie Cards (PSA)

What is the Price Development for Gary Rookie Cards (PSA)?

The Gary Rookie Cards (PSA) Trading Card has a current estimated value of USD 19.99, based on recent eBay sales.

Gary Rookie Cards (PSA) price by year

Year Sales Low Median High
2026 9 $10.50 $19.99 $59.99
2025 7 $7.06 $10.00 $24.57
2024 7 $7.50 $8.33 $22.00
2023 6 $7.15 $31.25 $75.00
Eligible eBay sale prices for Gary Rookie Cards (PSA) by year

Recent eBay Sales

Title Price Date
1989 Fleer - Gary Sheffield #196 (RC) Milwaukee Brewers PSA 10 Gem Mint Rookie $40.00 May 10, 2026
1990 Fleer Update Gary Payton ROOKIE Card #U-92 RC PSA 9 Mint $12.99 May 04, 2026
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC PSA 8 $14.99 Apr 28, 2026
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC PSA 9 AUTO 10 $225.00 Apr 21, 2026
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC PSA 9 AUTO 10 $225.00 Apr 20, 2026
1989 Fleer #196 Gary Sheffield RC Rookie Card PSA 10 GEM MINT $23.99 Apr 11, 2026
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC HOF PSA 9 MINT $20.00 Apr 06, 2026
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC PSA 10 $75.00 Mar 29, 2026
1989 Fleer Gary Sheffield Rookie RC #196 Brewers PSA 10 GEM MINT $30.00 Mar 29, 2026
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC PSA 9 $19.99 Mar 12, 2026
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC PSA 9 $19.99 Mar 11, 2026
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC PSA 9 $10.50 Mar 11, 2026
1989 FLEER #196 GARY SHEFFIELD ROOKIE RC PSA 10 GEM MINT $59.99 Mar 09, 2026
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC PSA 8 $10.00 Mar 13, 2025
1989 Fleer #196 Gary Sheffield Brewers RC Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT $24.57 Mar 04, 2025
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC PSA 7 $10.00 Mar 04, 2025
1990 Fleer Update Gary Payton RC PSA 8 #U-92 Rookie $7.99 Feb 25, 2025
Gary Sheffield - 1989 Fleer - PSA 10 - RC - ROOKIE $18.26 Feb 24, 2025
1989 FLEER #196 GARY SHEFFIELD ROOKIE RC PSA 9 $7.06 Feb 10, 2025
1989 Fleer Gary Sheffield #196 PSA 9 MINT Rookie RC $11.17 Feb 07, 2025
1990 FLEER UPDATE #U-92 GARY PAYTON ROOKIE RC PSA 9 $8.33 Dec 31, 2024
1989 Fleer Gary Sheffield Rookie RC #196 PSA 9 Mint Milwaukee Brewers  $12.99 Dec 31, 2024
1989 Fleer #196 Gary Sheffield Milwaukee Brewers Rc Rookie Psa 10 Gem Mint $14.50 Jun 20, 2024
1989 Fleer #196 Gary Sheffield Brewers Rookie RC PSA 8 $7.50 May 07, 2024
1989 Fleer #196 Gary Sheffield Brewers RC Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT $22.00 Apr 17, 2024
Showing 25 of 33 sales

Similar Trading Cards by value

Mac Jones Rookie Card

Mac Jones Rookie Card

$19.99
Josh Allen Rookie Card

Josh Allen Rookie Card

$19.99
Frank Thomas Rookie Card

Frank Thomas Rookie Card

$19.99
Pelicans Rookie Cards (PSA)

Pelicans Rookie Cards (PSA)

$19.99
Rookie Cards (SGC)

Rookie Cards (SGC)

$19.99
Jo Rookie Cards (PSA)

Jo Rookie Cards (PSA)

$19.99
Shaquille O'Neal Rookie Card

Shaquille O'Neal Rookie Card

$20.00
U-14 Rookie Cards (PSA)

U-14 Rookie Cards (PSA)

$20.00
U-68 Rookie Cards (PSA)

U-68 Rookie Cards (PSA)

$20.00
U-87 Rookie Cards (PSA)

U-87 Rookie Cards (PSA)

$19.98
Mc Rookie Cards (PSA)

Mc Rookie Cards (PSA)

$20.00
Warriors Rookie Cards (PSA)

Warriors Rookie Cards (PSA)

$20.44

Frequently asked questions

What is the current value of Gary Rookie Cards (PSA)?

The current estimated value of Gary Rookie Cards (PSA) is USD 19.99 based on recent eBay sales data.

What is the highest price paid for Gary Rookie Cards (PSA)?

The highest recorded eBay sale for Gary Rookie Cards (PSA) is USD 75.00, sold in Jun 2023.

What is the lowest price paid for Gary Rookie Cards (PSA)?

The lowest recorded eBay sale for Gary Rookie Cards (PSA) is USD 7.06, sold in Feb 2025.

What categories does Gary Rookie Cards (PSA) belong to?

Gary Rookie Cards (PSA) is part of: Rookie Cards, PSA.